The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time

The Xbox 360 is one of the best consoles ever released, so compiling a list of the best Xbox 360 games is no easy task.

Coming off the success of the original Xbox, Microsoft released a console that helped usher in the future of gaming. HD visuals, an improved Xbox Live, and the blueprints for modern game consoles and connectivity were all a part of what made the Xbox 360 great.

Of course, a console is nothing without its games. So let’s talk about the 25 best Xbox 360 games of all time.

Call of Duty 2

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Activision

The game that made me want an Xbox 360. Its impressive display of the intensity and brutality of war gave the game, and console, a next-gen feeling from day one. Its strength and quality were doubly impressive since the game was available on day one; launch titles are usually more lacking in quality. 

That wasn’t the case with Call of Duty 2. Instead, this was everything WWII shooters aspired to be and more. It helped take the franchise into the atmosphere of “an excellent FPS” into “genre-defining.” Somehow, though, it would be overtaken by….

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Activison

Modern Warfare improved everything that made Call of Duty 2 great. Taking the franchise into the present day was the best decision Infinity Ward could make; WWI fatigue was starting to set in.

This is the introduction of killstreaks, a defining feature of the franchise today. Overall, the multiplayer was vastly improved over what was an enjoyable, yet somewhat shallow, offering from Call of Duty 2. 

For all that made it one of the best shooters of all time, Infinity Ward would again best themselves one last time, with…

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Activison

While others may feel like the Black Ops franchise eventually overtook Modern Warfare, in my opinion, this is the pinnacle of the Call of Duty franchise.

Modern Warfare 2 had it all. The franchise’s best campaign features an over-the-top story, varied, colorful, and well-designed campaign environments, and a fantastic score from Hans Zimmer. Of course, it has the same addictive multiplayer we all know and love.

Infinity Ward went all out with Modern Warfare 2, putting all their cards on the table. While the Call of Duty franchise has continued to enjoy success, it’s yet to match the quality found here. It, and the two predecessors mentioned, easily make the list of best Xbox 360 games of all time. 

Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Activision

Geometry Wars started as a mini-game found in one of the best Xbox games of all time. It then morphed into my most played during the Xbox 360 launch. 

One of the original games released on the Xbox Live Arcade, Geometry Wars showed what was possible in terms of short, sweet, and satisfying digital release games. In addition, XBLA helped usher in a new type of game that still packed a punch but had a lower price tag (400 Microsoft Points, aka $5). 

It helped, too, that the game was a blast. The number of late nights spent trying to improve my score and climb the leaderboards and perform better than my friends helped prepare me for the wave of AAA online gaming that awaited me in the future. 

Castle Crashers

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: The Behemoth

Unlike the previously mentioned game, Castle Crashers had a higher price tag. However, it was still worth every penny.

A deep, engaging, challenging, and hilarious cooperative brawler, Castle Crashers helped put developer The Behemoth on the map. Castle Crashers was an exception in an age where online multiplayer was thriving. While online co-op was a thing, it wasn’t the ideal way to play the game. 

This was a couch co-op game through and through. One that brought friends together as they progressed through levels while having an absolute blast.

Is it possible that I look back on Castle Crashers a little too favorably? Sure, but it’s still hard to deny that it’s one of the best Xbox 360 games ever released.

Rock Band 2

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Electronic Arts

Speaking of couch co-op, we need to pay our respects to royalty. Though, technically, this wasn’t “couch” co-op and, instead, “stand up and play” co-op.

While the Rock Band franchise saw releases before and after, it’s hard to argue that Rock Band 2 is the pinnacle of the franchise. This was the peak of video game band fame; more songs, continuous DLC, endless parties, and no filler. It seemed like if you had a friend that was into gaming, they had plastic instruments somewhere in their house. 

While the fad has come and gone, the peak of Rock Band mania will never be forgotten. That’s why its on our list of the best Xbox 360 games. 

Gears of War

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Microsoft Studios

Let me tell you a story about my Gears of War launch experience. 

Instead of playing the campaign, I hopped online for some multiplayer. I was thrilled that matches were team-based 4v4 encounters, similar to Counter-Strike. When you die, you can’t respawn, but you are, unlike Counter-Strike, able to be revived by your teammates.

Unless, of course, an enemy comes and curb-stomps you. Or chainsaws your head off.

The number of nerdgasms over voice chat as blood splattered over our screen was endless. 

Gears of War multiplayer was, at the time, a change of pace compared to Halo. It was tactical, methodical, and tense. It was perfect for a LAN party a week after launch. It was the killer app for the Xbox 360 after launch and easily one of the best Xbox 360 games ever released.

Alan Wake

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Remedy Entertainment

Remedy’s atmospheric mystery thriller is an absolute delight. Blending several genres together, the “episodic” story takes us through the darkness and horrors of a small town in the Pacific Northwest. 

There’s no denying the immersion crafted into the game, whether it’s the story playing out like a TV series, the hidden show within the game “Night Springs,” or the importance of Wake’s profession as an author to the story. This is how Alan Wake hooks you; it doesn’t let you go with the survival horror-inspired combat and gameplay.

Best of all, a sequel is now in development!


The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Supergiant Games

Before Hades, there was Bastion. 

The debut game from indie dev Supergiant Games, Bastion is a work of art come to life. A solid action RPG with satisfying combat, plenty of depth, and a soothing narrator to tell the tale. Like others on this list, Bastion showcased what was possible from both indie developers and the Xbox Live Arcade selection of games. 

What’s doubly impressive is that this was Supergiant’s first game. Even today, it’s widely regarded as one of their best.


The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Number None

Braid is a puzzle game that looks like a platform. It’s a spin on the Super Mario formula for gaming. Navigate your way through a level and save the damsel in distress.

What makes Braid so great are two things. First, the gameplay. As mentioned earlier, this isn’t your typical platformer. Instead, time manipulation allows you to solve the puzzles that lay before you. Quick and clever thinking, not precious jumps and movements, will allow you to succeed. 

Second? The story. It’s an absolute delight that still holds up well today. 

Forza Horizon

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Microsoft Studios

Forza Horizon 5 is an absolute masterpiece. The original, though? It laid the foundation for one of the most successful and greatest racing franchises of all time.

While the Motorsport franchise was serious simulation gameplay, Horizon was all about fun and exploration. It’s shocking how well the game holds up, even if the soundtrack (featuring plenty of Skrillex) is a product of its time. 

Forza Horizon didn’t invent the open-world racer. It already existed on the Xbox 360 with Burnout Paradise. However, it accomplished a higher quality level thanks to pristine polish and refreshing accessibility.


The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: 2K Games

BioShock was one of the best games of its generation. While yes, it came up a little bit short in length, it was a memorable experience nonetheless.

On the surface, BioShock was an action RPG with a mild morality system. The narrative, location, and characters are what carried it, however. Rapture is a beautiful setting for a game, an underwater utopia gone wrong. The story is beyond memorable and one of the best found on the Xbox 360. 

If there’s ever a case study for a video game that nails atmosphere and setting, BioShock would be exhibits A, B, and C. 

Mass Effect

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Electronic Arts

Fresh off their success with Knights of the Old Republic and Jade Empire, BioWare delivered another smash hit with Mass Effect. Taking their narrative-driven RPG to space, the Xbox 360 exclusive wove a beautiful Sci-Fi tale, one where your choices and decisions matter throughout. 

Mass Effect is widely regarded as one of the best RPGs of all time, but for some, it’s not even the best in the franchise. Admittedly, while its strength was story and character building, combat was its weakness. This would, however, later be redeemed with…

Mass Effect 2

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Electronic Arts

…Mass Effect 2.

Now under the wing of Electronic Arts, BioWare delivered a sequel that built upon the original in just about every way. While sacrifices were made in terms of narrative, dialogue, and character focus, gameplay and combat were refined tenfold.

Storywise, Mass Effect 2 does suffer a bit from being the second game in a trilogy. Plotlines don’t really end, per se, but the game-specific narrative and climax do a good job of circumventing any lack of tension. 

Ultimately, the “preferred” game in the franchise comes down to personal preference. Either way, you can’t go wrong with either one of these as one of the best Xbox 360 games.  

Dead Rising

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Capcom

Trapped in a mall filled with thousands of zombies, one man must make it out alive.

Don’t worry; he’s covered wars, ya know. 

On the surface, Dead Rising is a serious race against time to escape a zombie-infested mall. The deeper you dig, the zanier and over-the-top the game becomes. It’s a zombie sandbox delight that doesn’t take itself too seriously. While Dead Rising may not have aged entirely too well, it’s still a joy to play. 

Elder Scrolls Iv: Oblivion

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Bethesda Softworks

While PC gaming is pretty mainstream today, it wasn’t always like that. For most, the arrival of Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion within the Xbox 360 launch window was the reason to buy the console. 

It did not disappoint.

Oblivion is a gorgeous, gigantic, and enchanting tale. It features a solid voice cast (aside from the side characters, of course), hilarious dialogue within its side quests, and a strong main narrative. It’s my favorite Elder Scrolls game. 

I’m serious. I definitely like it better than…

Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Bethesda Softworks

Skyrim is a game you can get lost in. You can wander the world and do anything your heart desires. You’ll forget why you’re headed to that town in the distance. Who knows what you’re looking for, but that doesn’t matter, because you’ll find something to do.

Before you know it, twenty hours have passed, and you’ve done pretty much nothing of substance. Other than enjoying yourself, that is. 

Skyrim’s weakest link, in my opinion, is the primary campaign. As a result, it fails to hook you in the way others have in the past. That said, there’s no denying its staying power as an ultimate fantasy open-world RPG. There’s a reason this is one of the more popular Bethesda games available.

Halo 3

The 26 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Microsoft Studios

Finally, we finished the fight. 

Halo 3 ended the trilogy and gave Master Chief his much-needed slumber. This is great because regardless of how you feel about the campaign, most of our time here was spent in multiplayer. If you ask me, it was time well spent.

Halo 3’s multiplayer expanded beyond its predecessor. The maps were better, the gameplay was tighter, and the memories were life-lasting. While the campaign may have stumbled, the multiplayer once again delivered. There honestly may never be anything like it again. 

Oh, and the TV spot is the greatest ad of all time, too. 

Grand Theft Auto V

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Rockstar Games

The fact that Grand Theft Auto V exists on the Xbox 360 hardware is a miracle. The fact that we haven’t gotten a new GTA release since this one is frustrating. 

All that aside, GTA V is an absolute marvel and a shining example of video game perfection. The world of Los Santos is alive and well, the characters are an absolute delight, and the gameplay is the best the franchise offers.

While Rockstar is currently content (as far as we know) with supporting Grand Theft Auto Online over GTA VI, it’s honestly hard to blame them. The framework that was set up in GTA V was rock solid. There’s a reason why the game has seen countless remasters and re-releases: it’s a work of art.

Dark Souls

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: FromSoftware, Inc.

Speaking of works of art, may I suggest Dark Souls?

The successor to the PlayStation 3 exclusive Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls refined the experience into an unforgiving, challenging, and satisfying experience on the Xbox 360. Dark Souls put developer FromSoftware and the entire genre of difficult action RPGs on the map.

We’ve since seen an avalanche of games inspired by Dark Souls that offer brutal difficulty and a rewarding game for those willing to invest. This includes both other games from FromSoftware, as well as other developers.

Still, there’s only one original. Long live the king.  


The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Bethesda Softworks

A blend of style and substance, Dishonored is a fantastic stealth-action game. Its open-ended nature, combined with super abilities, allows for expansive freedom for players to do as they will. 

What truly makes Dishonored great is that subsequent playthroughs can very easily differ. The world of Dunwall continuously changes based on your actions. This creates different experiences based on your playstyle. 

Visually, Dishonored is a gorgeous game to boot, too. Stealth action has never looked so good, and rarely has it ever played so well.

Super Meat Boy

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Team Meat

Yet another Xbox Live Arcade title, Super Meat Boy took the platformer genre and pushed it to the limits. 

Well-crafted and precise controls were welcomed and necessary; the game is brutally difficult. What’s remarkable, though, is the fact that nothing feels cheap or unfair. You know why you died or failed, and it’s always because of the user, not the game. 

Furthermore, the game isn’t overtly punishing out of nowhere. The difficulty curve is one of the finest in all of gaming.  

Left 4 Dead

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Valve

Left 4 Dead launched with four maps. By today’s standards, that’s a severe lack of depth. What it lacked there, however, it made up for in replayability and value.

The game’s hook was “The Director,” an AI which adapts to player performance. If you were handling the zombie outbreak a little too well, for example, ominous music would start playing, an enemy Tank would appear, and your day would be ruined. 

What made Left 4 Dead so enjoyable was how well polished the cooperative and competitive gameplay was. Many fond memories were made attempting to speedrun through the campaign and some beautiful 4v4 multiplayer action.


The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Microsoft Studios

It was often joked at Crackdown’s release that people spent $60 to play in the Halo 3 multiplayer beta and received a free game alongside it. As it turns out, that “free game” was an absolute blast to play regarding arcade-style open-world action shooters. 

The premise of Crackdown was simple: become super powerful. The execution followed through on this, allowing players to mow down enemies, jump and run long distances, and become as close to a deity as possible. Within reason, that is; we’re not talking about anything regarding superpowers.

Crackdown was a surprise hit that was a blast to play, easily earning it the title of one of the best Xbox 360 games.  

Gears of War 2

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Microsoft Studios

I kept you waiting on this one, didn’t I?

I have more fond memories of the original, but it’s impossible to deny how good the sequel is. Gears of War 2 is a game where you can easily knock out the campaign in a day. Not just because it’s on the shorter end in terms of length but also because of how much fun it is. Playing it co-op with a friend makes it even better.  

The real joy, though, is Gears of War 2’s Horde Mode, allowing you to endlessly mow down enemies until there are too many of them. The additional mode allowed for even more replayability to an enjoyable gameplay loop of a co-op campaign and multiplayer.

While the franchise has fallen off recently, those who remember playing through during release know how good the Gears trilogy was on Xbox 360. 

Halo: Reach

The 25 Best Xbox 360 Games of All Time
Photo Credit: Microsoft Studios

One of the most beautiful, compelling, and depressing games of all time, Halo: Reach, is the pinnacle of the Halo franchise.

Its multiplayer was enjoyable and complete with a variety of customization options. It was a true swan song for Bungie. What makes Halo: Reach so memorable, though, is the campaign. Reach is the total package with a challenging, deep, and engaging narrative combined with Halo gameplay perfected. It will shake you to the core, even with the knowledge of the fact that you know exactly how it ends.

One of the best Xbox 360 games ever made, Halo: Reach is one of the best shooters ever made, period.


Written by Jake Valentine

I am the Editor-In-Chief of BossLevelGamer. I'm also a lover of video games, food, and beer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *